Your account was flagged as a duplicate of an existing one. If you think this is a mistake please reach to support through our messaging system on the website or email support@lofty.ai

Click here to complete verification and unlock investing, deposits, and withdrawals. →

InvestAboutLearnLendingList Property
Log InSign Up

Real Estate Platform Comparison· Updated May 5, 2026

CrowdStreet vs. RealtyMogul 2026 Real Estate Investing Comparison

A side-by-side breakdown of returns, liquidity, fees, and trustworthiness to help you decide where to invest your money.

★ Our PickCrowdStreet logo
3.0

CrowdStreet is a credible way for accredited investors to access vetted commercial real estate deals, but $25,000 minimums, sponsor-driven fees, and 3–10 year holds put it out of reach for most retail investors. The 2022 Nightingale fraud case is also a sobering reminder that sponsor risk on crowdfunding platforms is real.

RealtyMogul logo
3.0

RealtyMogul is a credible, established option for investors who want exposure to commercial real estate REITs. The $5,000 minimum, multi-tier fees, and 3-year minimum hold for redemption make it best for buy-and-hold investors with mid-sized portfolios.

At a Glance

CrowdStreet vs. RealtyMogul — Key Stats

CrowdStreet logo
RealtyMogul logo
$25,000Minimum$5,000 (REITs); $25,000–$50,000+ (private placements)
3–7 years typical (can extend to 10+)Holding Period3-year minimum before penalty-free redemption (REITs); 5+ years (private placements)
Unavailable — no secondary marketEarly WithdrawalQuarterly redemption with discount in years 1–3; not guaranteed
Per project (typically quarterly)Rent PayoutMonthly distributions (Income REIT); quarterly (Apartment Growth REIT)
~18.3% historical IRR before fees on realized dealsAvg. ReturnsIncome REIT targets 6–8% annual distributions; private placements target higher IRR

Pros & Cons

What each platform does well and poorly

CrowdStreet logo
  • ✓

    Institutional-quality commercial deals

    CrowdStreet curates commercial real estate deals — multifamily, industrial, hospitality, medical office, data centers — that retail investors typically cannot access directly.

  • ✓

    Comprehensive deal documentation

    Each offering ships with a detailed business plan, sponsor profile, financial model, and a project launch webinar. Documentation depth is among the best in the space.

  • ✓

    Long track record

    Founded in 2014, CrowdStreet has facilitated more than 600 commercial real estate deals worth over $4 billion since launch. The platform publishes performance data on realized deals and an investor portal that aggregates across the portfolio.

  • ✓

    Vetted sponsors

    CrowdStreet approves only a small percentage of sponsor applicants (publicly cited ~2–5%) and runs background, asset, and offering-terms reviews on each listing.

  • ✗

    $25,000 minimum

    Most offerings require a $25,000 commitment, which prevents proper diversification for all but high-net-worth investors. Spreading capital across 5+ deals (the typical recommendation) requires $125k+.

  • ✗

    Accredited investors only

    CrowdStreet is closed to non-accredited investors. You must verify $200k+ income ($300k for couples) or $1M+ net worth excluding primary residence.

  • ✗

    Long lock-ups, sponsor-controlled exits

    Hold periods are typically 3–7 years and CrowdStreet warns investors may be forced to hold for 10+ years. Sponsors decide when to sell. There is no secondary market.

  • ✗

    Sponsor risk and the Nightingale case

    In 2022–2023, Nightingale Properties offerings on CrowdStreet were the subject of a high-profile fraud case. In February 2025, Nightingale CEO Elie Schwartz pleaded guilty to wire fraud involving roughly $54 million raised from CrowdStreet investors. The episode forced the platform to overhaul its escrow controls and remains a key cautionary tale about sponsor risk on crowdfunding platforms.

  • ✗

    Returns reported before fees

    CrowdStreet's headline 18.3% historical IRR is calculated before sponsor fees. Sponsor fees can be substantial and vary deal-by-deal, materially reducing what investors actually receive.

RealtyMogul logo
  • ✓

    Long track record

    Founded in 2012, RealtyMogul is one of the original real estate crowdfunding platforms. The company has publicly reported deploying more than $1 billion of investor capital across hundreds of properties since founding.

  • ✓

    Real commercial REIT exposure

    MogulREIT I (Income) and MogulREIT II (Apartment Growth) give non-accredited investors exposure to institutional-quality commercial real estate — multifamily, office, retail, industrial.

  • ✓

    Monthly Income REIT distributions

    MogulREIT I pays distributions monthly — more frequent than most peer REIT platforms — and has historically targeted 6–8% annualized distribution yield.

  • ✓

    Penalty-free redemption after 3 years

    Both MogulREITs offer a quarterly share repurchase program. After 3 years held, investors can redeem at full NAV (subject to availability).

  • ✗

    $5,000 REIT minimum

    RealtyMogul's REIT minimum is 50x Lofty's and 500x Fundrise's. The high minimum makes it harder to test the platform or diversify without committing real capital.

  • ✗

    Complex, layered fees

    RealtyMogul charges a 1–1.25% asset management fee plus organization, offering, and acquisition fees that vary by product. Private placements add sponsor-level fees on top.

  • ✗

    Early redemption discounts

    Redemption requests in years 1–2 are discounted (typically 2–4% off NAV) and not guaranteed if there's insufficient liquidity in the share repurchase program.

  • ✗

    Most deals are accredited-only

    Only the two MogulREITs are open to non-accredited investors. Individual private placements and 1031 exchange deals require accredited status.

Deep Dive

Detailed comparison

CrowdStreet logo
RealtyMogul logo

What You're Investing In

Individual commercial real estate deals (multifamily, industrial, hospitality, office, retail, medical office, data centers, parking) and the C-REIT diversified fund. Most carry a $25,000 minimum.

MogulREIT I (income-focused, monthly distributions), MogulREIT II (apartment growth, quarterly distributions), and individual private placements (accredited only, 5+ year holds, higher minimums).

Property Locations

Deals span the U.S. with concentration in growth-market metros — Texas, Florida, Arizona, Georgia, the Carolinas, Tennessee, and the Mountain West. Each project's location is disclosed in its offering documents.

Properties are spread across the U.S. with concentration in growth metros — Texas, Florida, Georgia, the Carolinas, Tennessee, Arizona, and select coastal cities. Each deal's location is disclosed in the offering documents.

Expected Returns

CrowdStreet reports a historical realized IRR of approximately 18.3% before fees across exited deals. After typical sponsor fees, real net IRR is meaningfully lower and varies deal-by-deal. Some realized deals have lost all investor capital — a reality CrowdStreet discloses in its annual performance report.

MogulREIT I targets 6–8% annualized distributions with limited NAV appreciation. MogulREIT II targets growth (apartment value appreciation) with smaller current distributions. Private placements target higher IRRs (often 12–18%) but carry deal-specific risk and longer holds.

Fees

Reported returns are gross of fees. Sponsors charge investors whatever they see fit — fees can exceed 20% of invested capital over the hold period. CrowdStreet itself charges sponsors 0.5–2% to list, indirectly built into deal pricing.

RealtyMogul charges 1–1.25% asset management on REITs plus organization, offering, and acquisition fees that vary by deal. Private placements layer sponsor fees (acquisition, asset management, disposition) on top. Investors should read each deal's full fee schedule.

Liquidity

Hold periods are typically 3–7 years. CrowdStreet's own disclosures warn investors may be forced to hold for 10+ years if sponsors delay sale.

Both MogulREITs offer a quarterly share repurchase program. After 3 years held, redemption is at full NAV, subject to availability. Private placements typically run 5+ years with no early-exit option.

Who Can Invest

Accredited investors only. Verification of income ($200k+ individual / $300k+ couple) or net worth ($1M+ excluding primary residence) is required before investing.

MogulREITs are open to non-accredited and accredited U.S. investors. Private placements and 1031 exchange offerings are restricted to accredited investors only.

The Verdict

Which is better — CrowdStreet or RealtyMogul?

★ Our Pick
CrowdStreet logo
3.0

CrowdStreet is a credible option for high-net-worth, accredited investors who want curated access to institutional commercial real estate. Documentation is strong, the sponsor vetting is real, and historical IRRs look attractive. But the $25,000 minimum, sponsor-controlled exits, lack of secondary market, and the lessons of the 2022 Nightingale case make this a platform that demands sophistication and diversification. Retail investors and anyone looking for liquidity will find better options elsewhere.

Full CrowdStreet review →
RealtyMogul logo
3.0

RealtyMogul is a credible, well-established option for mid-sized investors who want exposure to commercial real estate REITs with monthly distributions and the option of accredited-only private placements. The trade-offs are real: a $5,000 minimum that limits diversification, layered fees, and a 3-year minimum hold for penalty-free redemption mean RealtyMogul rewards committed buy-and-hold investors. Investors with smaller capital, those wanting daily payouts or a 24/7 exchange, or those focused on direct property-level ownership will find better fit elsewhere.

Full RealtyMogul review →

Bottom Line

CrowdStreet scores higher (3.0/5) and edges out RealtyMogul on our investment quality criteria.

CrowdStreet is a credible way for accredited investors to access vetted commercial real estate deals, but $25,000 minimums, sponsor-driven fees, and 3–10 year holds put it out of reach for most retail investors. The 2022 Nightingale fraud case is also a sobering reminder that sponsor risk on crowdfunding platforms is real.

Frequently Asked Questions

CrowdStreet vs. RealtyMogul FAQ

Which is better — CrowdStreet or RealtyMogul?+

Based on our scoring criteria — returns, fees, liquidity, transparency, minimums, and track record — CrowdStreet (3.0/5) scores higher than RealtyMogul (3.0/5). CrowdStreet is a credible way for accredited investors to access vetted commercial real estate deals, but $25,000 minimums, sponsor-driven fees, and 3–10 year holds put it out of reach for most retail investors. The 2022 Nightingale fraud case is also a sobering reminder that sponsor risk on crowdfunding platforms is real.

What is the minimum investment for CrowdStreet vs. RealtyMogul?+

CrowdStreet's minimum investment is $25,000. RealtyMogul's minimum investment is $5,000 (REITs); $25,000–$50,000+ (private placements).

How do CrowdStreet and RealtyMogul compare on liquidity?+

CrowdStreet: Hold periods are typically 3–7 years. CrowdStreet's own disclosures warn investors may be forced to hold for 10+ years if sponsors delay sale. RealtyMogul: Both MogulREITs offer a quarterly share repurchase program. After 3 years held, redemption is at full NAV, subject to availability. Private placements typically run 5+ years with no early-exit option.

What returns can investors expect from CrowdStreet vs. RealtyMogul?+

CrowdStreet reports average yearly returns of ~18.3% historical IRR before fees on realized deals. RealtyMogul reports average yearly returns of Income REIT targets 6–8% annual distributions; private placements target higher IRR. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

One of the most flexible ways to invest in real estate

Start building generational wealth with Lofty

$50 minimums · Daily rent payouts · No lock-up periods · 24/7 exchange

View PropertiesGet started free →
Lofty

Buy and own real estate shares. Earn daily rent. Sell anytime.

Start investing→

Follow us

Invest

  • Invest
  • Lending
  • List your property

Company

  • About us
  • Reviews
  • Compare

Resources

  • Investing guides
  • Calculators
  • Blog
  • Help center
  • Refer a friend
  • Store
  • Contact us

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Disclosures

This site is operated by Lofty AI, Inc., which is not a registered broker-dealer or investment advisor. Lofty AI, Inc. does not provide investment advice, endorsement or recommendations with respect to any properties listed on this site. Nothing on this website should be construed as an offer to sell, solicitation of an offer to buy or a recommendation in respect of a security. You are solely responsible for determining whether any investment, investment strategy or related transaction is appropriate for you based on your personal investment objectives, financial circumstances and risk tolerance. You should consult with licensed legal professionals and investment advisors for any legal, tax, insurance or investment advice. Lofty AI, Inc. does not guarantee any investment performance, outcome or return of capital for any investment opportunity posted on this site. By accessing this site and any pages thereof, you agree to be bound by the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

All investments involve risk and may result in partial or total loss. By accessing this site, investors understand and acknowledge 1) that investing in real estate, like investing in other fields, is risky and unpredictable; 2) that the real estate industry has its ups and downs; 3) that the real property you invest in might not result in a positive cash flow or perform as you expected; and 4) that the value of any real property you invest in may decline at any time and the future property value is unpredictable. Before making an investment decision, prospective investors are advised to review all available information and consult with their tax and legal advisors. Lofty AI does not provide investment advice or recommendations regarding any offering posted on this website.

Any investment-related information contained herein has been secured from sources that Lofty AI believes to be reliable, but we make no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or completeness of such information and accept no liability therefore. Hyperlinks to third-party sites, or reproduction of third-party articles, do not constitute an approval or endorsement by Lofty AI of the linked or reproduced content.

Lofty Marketplace trades are completed using USD Coin (USDC cryptocurrency) and smart contracts on a blockchain. If you use a payment method other than USDC to submit a buy order for a traded property, then you agree to purchase an equivalent quantity of USDC at the then current exchange rate. That is, you agree that your currency will be converted to USDC, and your buy order will be executed using USDC. USDC is a 1:1 representation of the US dollar on the blockchain that may fluctuate in value. In the event that your order is cancelled or expires, any unspent USDC will be returned to your Lofty Wallet. If you later submit a sell order for your property shares, and your sell order is filled, you will receive payment in USDC which can be converted to USD via third party cryptocurrency exchanges.

© 2026 Lofty AI, Inc.·Privacy·Terms

Version: dev

LOFTY